Evidence on performance  
      California Telecommunicating Project 
      Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration Project (telework centre 
      in Seattle)  
      Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration Project (City of Redmond, 
      WA, USA)  
      The main idea in telecommuting (teleworking) is taking the work to the 
        worker rather than the other way round. Even though the idea was introduced 
        as early as the 1950s it was not until the mid 1990s that the idea of 
        telecommuting took off. Several factors have been instrumental for the 
        wide spread acceptance of the concept; emergence of new organisational 
        shapes, based on flexibility, networking and individualisation of work, 
        the changing work process, the changing composition of the labour force, 
        dominated by information workers, and the creation of a non-standard flexible 
        workforce. In addition the wide spread acceptance of computers as a household 
        technology occurred in the same period and telecommunications advances 
        has made possible the transmission of large amount of data anywhere in 
        the world instantaneously. These forces have given rise to the growth 
        of acceptance of telecommuting and as a tool for transport demand management. 
        It is very likely that telecommuting will continue to grow in importance 
        to the workers in the post-industrial societies and to urban transport. 
      Three US case studies are presented in detail below. In addition, early 
        studies in the Netherlands and the US have shown that, for carefully selected 
        groups of teleworkers, the total number of journeys made could fall by 
        half or more, with non-work trips also falling, and, in the US study, 
        total travel distance falling by three quaters as presented in Travel 
        Reductions for Teleworkers. 
      
         
          |    | 
            Netherlands*  | 
            US**  | 
         
         
          |   Trips/day  | 
            -17%  | 
            -51%  | 
         
         
          |   Work trips/day  | 
            -15%  | 
            -91%  | 
         
         
          |   Non work trips/day  | 
            -14%  | 
            -38%  | 
         
         
          |   Am peak trips/day  | 
            -26%  | 
            -73%  | 
         
         
          |   Trip-km/day  | 
            na  | 
            -75%  | 
         
       
      * All trips, when 20% of work trips are replaced. Data from Hamer et 
        al (1991) 
        ** Telecommuting trips only. Data from Pendyala et al (1991) 
      UK research suggests that around 40% of commuters would prefer to work 
        at home, and that on average thay would aim to work at home on four days 
        per week. The current US rate is 2.5 days per week. Based on these surveys, 
        dodgson et al (1997) provide estimates of the possioble reductions in 
        car use from teleworking, teleconferencing and teleshopping, as presented 
        in Potential Trip Changes. 
       
      
         
          |    | 
            2002  | 
            2007  | 
            2017  | 
         
         
          |   Conservative scenario  | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
         
         
          |   Commuting  | 
            -6  | 
            -11  | 
            -22  | 
         
         
          |   Other business travel  | 
            -4  | 
            -5  | 
            -10  | 
         
         
          |   Shopping: cars  | 
            -1  | 
            -2  | 
            -4  | 
         
         
          |   Delivery vans  | 
            +0.1  | 
            +0.2  | 
            +0.4  | 
         
         
          |   Optimistic Scenario  | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
         
         
          |   Commuting  | 
            -9  | 
            -18  | 
            -36  | 
         
         
          |   Other business travel  | 
            -14  | 
            -20  | 
            -40  | 
         
         
          |   Shopping: cars  | 
            -3  | 
            -6  | 
            -11  | 
         
         
          |   Delivery vans  | 
            +0.3  | 
            +0.6  | 
            +1.1  | 
         
       
       
        
       
      California Telecommunicating Project 
      Context 
        The programme was introduced in 1988 to evaluate the role of telecommuting 
        in San Francisco, Sacramento and Los Angeles in reducing traffic and air 
        pollution and to evaluate the reduction of trips. The target group was 
        state employees. The programme provided options for physically disabled 
        people. Telecommuting was predominantly home-based using telephone and 
        PCs. Telecommuters were on the average 41 years. More than half of the 
        participants (about 150-252) in the programme were men (64%). The number 
        of days of telecommuting ranged from 1.6 to over 3 days per week. Only 
        those with over 3 telecommute days per week required a dedicated line 
        for connecting to computer facilities at work. Most participants had PCs 
        at home. Laptops were provided to telecommuters.  
      Impacts on demand 
        The reduction of work trips due to telecommuting was not offset by the 
        generation of new non-work trips by telecommuters and their household. 
        The findings in this project point to potentials for reductions in vehicle 
        kilometres and reductions in peak period travel by car due to telecommuting. 
        Those who telecommute choose non-work destinations that are closer to 
        home.  
      Impacts on Supply 
        Not available 
        
        Contribution to Objectives 
      
         
          |   Objective   | 
            Comment  | 
         
         
          |    
  | 
            Reductions in car use as the result of telecommuting  | 
         
         
          |     
            
  | 
            By improving sense of community and positive impacts 
              on local businesses.  | 
         
         
          |     
            
  | 
            The reduction in car use contributes to reductions 
              in emissions.  | 
         
         
          |     
            
  | 
            Improved access for physically disabled  | 
         
         
          |     
            
  | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |     
            
  | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            The cost of implementing was related to the telephone 
              services for telecommuters  | 
         
       
        
       
       
      Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration Project (telework 
        centre in Seattle) 
      Context 
        The focus of the programme was on a telework centre that was established 
        in North Seattle, supporting state employees who normally worked in a 
        central location (Olympia). The centre was equipped with conference room, 
        lunchroom, computer room and workstation area. There were on-site hardware 
        and software support. The project started in October 1990 and was terminated 
        in January 1992. Altogether 24 telecommuters used the centre. The state 
        of Washington provided the financial support. More than half used the 
        centre regularly while others used the centre less than one day in two 
        weeks. Some preferred to telecommute from home.  
      Impacts on demand 
        The centre did not reduce the number of work trips, but did reduce the 
        number of vehicle kilometres. 
      Impacts on Supply 
      Not addressed  
      
         
          |   Objective   | 
            Comment   | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Reductions in vehicle kilometres and peak period 
              travel by car  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed   | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Reduction in emission related to the decrease in 
              vehicle kilometres  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed   | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            The state of Washington supported the initiative  | 
         
       
        
       
      Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration Project (City 
        of Redmond, WA, USA) 
      Context 
        The programme was initiated by City of Redmond in 1990. The primary objective 
        of the programmes was to evaluate the impacts of telecommuting on demand 
        for travel. There were 10 official participants and 10-15 unofficial participants 
        in the programme. The technologies used in this programme were PCs, modems, 
        and standard telephone services for home-based telecommuting. The laptops 
        were provided by the city. 
      Impacts on demand 
        All participants reported a reduction of commute trips amounting to 13-17 
        percent. The reduction in commute trips did not generate additional non-work 
        trips among the participants. 
         
        Impacts on Supply 
        Not addressed  
       
      
         
          |   Objective   | 
            Comment   | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            The reductions in vehicle kilometres and peak period 
              travel by car  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Reduction in emission related to the decrease in 
              vehicle kilometres   | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            Not addressed  | 
         
         
          |      
              | 
            The City of Redmond supported the initiative  | 
         
       
      Gaps and Weaknesses 
        There are some important gaps and weaknesses in the evidence on the impacts 
        of telecommuting of travel behaviour. Most demonstration programmes studies 
        have been limited in scale and only address the short-term impacts of 
        telecommuting on travel behaviour of the participants in the programme 
        and their households in some cases. The respondents in these demonstration 
        programmes are usually carefully selected and their travel behaviour adjustments 
        might not be representative. The longer-term impacts, in terms of decisions 
        related to the locations of residence and work are not addressed in these 
        studies. The projections of reductions in congestion might be an overestimation 
        in the presence of a latent demand.  
       
          
       
       
        
  
      
        
        
       |